What Are the Different Types of Malpractice Damages?
|
Legal malpractice damages generally fall into four categories: compensatory damages (the “case within a case” losses you actually suffered), consequential damages (additional losses caused by the attorney’s error), punitive damages (rare, reserved for egregious misconduct), and, in some cases, disgorgement of fees paid to the attorney. |
Proving your attorney made a mistake is often the easy part of a legal malpractice case. The harder part, the part that decides whether you actually recover anything, is proving what that mistake cost you. That dollar figure comes from one (or more) of four recognized types of damages:
- Compensatory damages: What your original case was actually worth before the attorney’s error.
- Consequential damages: Additional losses the error caused beyond the case itself.
- Punitive damages: Rare awards reserved for grossly negligent, reckless, or intentional misconduct.
- Fee disgorgement: Recovery of fees you already paid the attorney who caused the harm; applicable for more egregious conduct.
Below, we’ll break down each type of legal malpractice damage, how courts calculate them, and what evidence you’ll need to prove your claim.
How legal malpractice damages work
Damages recoverable in cases of legal malpractice in Texas are primarily (although not always exclusively) economic damages. Legal malpractice damages are essentially always the difference between what a client should have received if it weren’t for their lawyer’s actions/omissions and what they actually received. Because of this, emotional distress or pain and suffering damages are not generally on the table in Texas legal malpractice cases.
Here’s another way to look at it: legal malpractice cases are essentially two cases, also known as “a case within a case.” Whatever damages were allowed in the underlying case (your first case that your attorney messed up), you are now allowed to pursue and recover in the new legal malpractice case that will be filed against your attorney(s).
Basically, the examples of legal malpractice in Texas that are recoverable include whatever damages you were able to recover from your previous case. You generally cannot tack on pain and suffering or emotional distress damages against your lawyer, but you can right their wrongs by suing them for screwing up your case.
1. Compensatory damages
Compensatory damages form the foundation of nearly every legal malpractice case. They’re calculated by looking at what your original case was actually worth before your attorney’s mistake got in the way, often called the “case within a case.” If you can show what you would have won (in all probability) and prove your attorney’s mistake is why you didn’t win it, compensatory damages are how you get made whole.
How courts calculate the “case within a case”
To win compensatory damages, you have to essentially litigate two cases at once:
- The malpractice claim itself
- The underlying case your attorney mishandled
That means proving what a reasonable outcome would have been if your attorney had done their job. This usually requires expert testimony from another attorney who can speak to what a competent lawyer would have done differently.
What you need to prove
To recover compensatory damages, you must show that the attorney owed you a duty of care, that they breached it, that the breach caused you harm, and that the harm has a calculable value. Skipping any one of these steps is why so many otherwise valid claims fall apart.
2. Consequential damages
Consequential damages cover the losses that ripple out from your attorney’s error, beyond just the value of your original case. These are often easier to calculate because they’re usually related to your out of pocket/economic damages incurred by you as a result of the malpractice.
This could include the money you paid to pay a judgment that should not have been awarded against you; the appellate fees you paid to try to fix the attorney’s errors; or the money you paid to subsequent attorneys to try to fix the problem and avoid the damages. Think of them as the collateral damage of a mishandled case.
Losses beyond the case value
If a missed deadline forced you to file bankruptcy, cost you a business opportunity, or damaged your credit while you waited for a resolution that never came, those losses can sometimes count too. Consequential damages exist because malpractice rarely stays contained to just the case file.
How consequential damages show up in malpractice lawsuits
In malpractice lawsuits, consequential damages can sometimes be contested because the connection between the attorney’s error and the loss has to be direct and foreseeable. Courts won’t award damages for losses that are too speculative or too far removed from the original mistake.
3. Punitive damages
Punitive damages aren’t about compensating you. They exist to punish an attorney whose conduct went beyond ordinary negligence and into something reckless or intentional. Because of that, they’re awarded far less often than compensatory or consequential damages.
Can you get punitive damages for legal malpractice?
Yes, but only in limited circumstances. Punitive damages typically require clear and convincing evidence that your attorney acted with malice, fraud, or gross negligence, not just a mistake or an oversight. A missed deadline alone usually won’t clear that bar.
Among successful legal malpractice cases involving punitive damages, the pattern is consistent: the attorney’s conduct wasn’t just careless; it was deliberate, fraudulent, intentional, or shockingly indifferent to the client’s interests.
What makes a case “egregious” enough
Courts look for a pattern of misconduct, not an isolated slip. Falsifying records, actively concealing a mistake from a client, or knowingly missing a deadline to avoid extra work are just a few examples of the kinds of conduct that can push a case into punitive territory.
4. Fee disgorgement
Fee disgorgement is the recovery of money you already paid your attorney, on top of whatever else is owed or outstanding. It’s based on a simple principle: if your attorney didn’t provide competent representation, they shouldn’t get to keep what you paid them for it.
What fee disgorgement actually covers
Disgorgement isn’t automatically a full refund of every fee you ever paid. Courts can order partial disgorgement tied to the specific work compromised by the breach, or full disgorgement when the misconduct amounted to a serious breach of fiduciary duty, such as a conflict of interest or dishonesty with a client. The amount usually depends on how directly the misconduct undermined the value of what you were paying for. Notably, the court/judge, not a jury, decides the amount, if any, of fee disgorgement.
Fee disgorgement versus compensatory damages
Disgorgement is not the same as compensatory damages, and you don’t have to choose between them. Compensatory damages ask what your case was worth. Disgorgement asks whether the attorney earned the fee at all. That distinction is why fee disgorgement often comes up in malpractice lawsuits built around ethical violations, not just missed deadlines or procedural errors.
When to sue your attorney for malpractice over fees
If you paid an attorney and later learned they had an undisclosed conflict of interest, misrepresented the work they did on your case, or breached client confidentiality, that may be enough to justify a disgorgement claim on its own. Answering when to sue your attorney for malpractice over fees usually comes down to the breach itself, not just the outcome of your case.
These claims can be harder to prove than a straightforward negligence case, which is why working with attorneys that sue attorneys, and specifically a legal malpractice lawyer in Houston familiar with fee disgorgement claims, matters.
FAQs
How long do you have to sue for legal malpractice in Texas?
In most cases, Texas gives you two years from the date the malpractice occurred to file suit. In some cases the clock doesn’t start running until the underlying case you were involved in has been fully resolved, but in others it starts on the date that you discover your attorney’s malpractice. Because the exact accrual date can get complicated, it’s worth talking to an attorney as soon as you suspect a problem rather than waiting.
Do you need a new attorney to sue your old one?
Yes, you should hire a different attorney to represent you in a legal malpractice claim against your original one. Malpractice cases require specialized knowledge of both the underlying area of law and the standards attorneys are held to, so most malpractice attorneys focus specifically on these claims rather than general practice.
What percentage of malpractice cases settle?
A significant portion of legal malpractice claims are resolved through settlement rather than trial, similar to most civil litigation. Whether a case settles typically depends on how clear the evidence of negligence is, how well the damages can be documented, and who you hired to sue your old attorney. Cases where you have hired the best and most competent attorney, complete with strong documentation and expert support, tend to settle faster and more favorably.
What is the average payout for a malpractice lawsuit?
There’s no reliable “average” payout because settlements and verdicts depend heavily on what the underlying case was worth, the strength of the evidence, and the type of damages involved. A case with clear compensatory damages tied to a specific financial loss will look very different from one seeking punitive damages or fee disgorgement. An attorney can give you a realistic range once they’ve reviewed the specifics of your case.
Your attorney owed you better results. We’ll help you prove it.
When an attorney’s negligence costs you money, opportunity, or a case you should have won, you have the right to pursue legal malpractice damages, whether that’s compensatory damages, consequential losses, punitive damages, or the fees you already paid. But proving what happened, and what it cost you, requires an attorney who knows exactly how these cases are built and won.
Ross Sears II has a 100% success rate at trial in legal malpractice cases and cases against attorneys, giving you a proven advocate when the person who was supposed to protect you let you down.
Call (713) 223-3333 or contact us today to talk through what happened and find out what you may be owed.
More Helpful Articles by Sears Crawford:
